Introduction : the panda's black box / Nathaniel C. Comfort -- The argument from design / Michael Ruse -- The aerodynamics of flying carpets : why biologists are loath to "teach the controversy" / Scott F. Gilbert and the Swarthmore College Evolution and Development Seminar -- The classroom controversy : a history of the dispute over teaching evolution / Edward J. Larson -- Untangling debates about science and religion / Jane Maienschein -- Intelligent design : a symptom of metaphysical malaise / Robert Maxwell Young.